Understanding Valuation Measures
First, let's take a moment to define what we're trying to measure. Valuation is a measure of how expensive a stock price is relative to the underlying business. There are several different attributes we can use to determine valuation. Just as you might judge the price of a car based on it's styling, engine power, features, and brand, you judge the price of a business based on it's earnings, net assets, cash flows, and revenues.
1) Price to Earnings Ratio (P/E)What does it tell you?
How expensive a stock is relative to reported net profits. A higher P/E ratio indicates a more expensive stock relative to earnings.How do you calculate it?
Stock Price / Earnings Per Share (trailing twelve months)
Forward P/E is used to determine what the P/E ratio should look like a year from now, based on earnings projections. This is useful if trailing earnings included sizable earnings gains or losses that were one-time in nature. It is calculated similarly:
Stock Price / Earnings Per Share (expected 1 year ahead)What's good or bad?
The market at large has averaged about 15-17 P/E for much of the last 30 years. Some sectors average lower P/E ratios (like energy), and some average higher P/E ratios (like technology). As a rule, a P/E ratio under 10 is very low, and one over 30 is considered rather high.Simple example
Johnson and Johnson (JNJ) earned a net profit of 3.63 per share of stock in 2007. The stock price today is 62.63. Therefore P/E is (62.63 / 3.63) = 17.24.
2) Price to Book Ratio (P/B)What does it tell you?
"Book value" refers to the net worth of the company's property, buildings, equipment, cash, and other assets, minus bills outstanding, wages owed to employees, debt, and other liabilities. In essence, book value is what the company would be worth if liquidated. Most companies sell at a premium to book value because the company can generate profits from these assets.How do you calculate it?
Stock Price / Book Value Per Share (most recent quarter)What's good or bad?
Price to book is most useful for valuing companies where growth in assets is the goal of the business. Banks, insurance companies, and investment firms are good examples. It is a poor statistic for valuing companies where assets are primarily non-physical, like software and media companies. Benjamin Graham was a well known proponent of buying stocks under book value - although this is difficult to do today. A price-to-book value under 1.0 is really cheap, and under 2 is often considered a favorable valuation for asset based businesses.Simple example
Johnson and Johnson's reported net equity (same as book value) was about $15 per share for 2007. Using a stock price of 62.63, this gives us a price to book ratio of (62.63 / 15) = 4.18.
3) Price to Sales Ratio (P/S)What does it tell you?
Simply compares the stock price to the amount of sales per share the company has brought in over the last 12 months.How do you calculate it?
Stock Price / Sales per Share (trailing twelve months)What's good or bad?
The P/S ratio is highly correlative with net margin (discussed in last week's article). Higher net margin leads to a higher P/S ratio, because the company converts a higher percentage of sales to profits. The P/S ratio is considered less useful than the other valuation statistics by MagicDiligence. I recommend only using it to compare against other companies in the same business, or against historical averages of the stock being considered.Simple example
Johnson and Johnson earned about $20.99 in sales per share of stock for 2007. Using the stock price of 62.63, this gives us a price to sales ratio of (62.63 / 20.99) = 2.96.
4) Price to Cash Flow (P/CF)What does it tell you?
This ratio is very similar to P/E, except it uses the cash flow per share instead of earnings. This cuts out non-cash earnings and charges like depreciation and changes in working capital. This is a better measure of the actual dollars being generated by the business. Cash flow is generally what most people think of when doing their own finances.How do you calculate it?
Stock Price / Cash Flow per Share (trailing twelve months)
Cash flow can be garnered from the Statement of Cash Flows, under Cash Provided By Operating Activities.What's good or bad?
Studies have been published that show that companies with higher cash flow numbers than earnings are better performers over the long run. Compare P/CF with P/E and if it is a lower number, consider this a positive sign.Simple example
Johnson and Johnson delivered 5.28 of cash flow per share in 2007, well over it's 3.63 of reported earnings. This is because the company accounted for depreciation of it's equipment, amortization of it's intangible assets, and other accounting tricks that allow the company to pay lower taxes. But the actual amount of cash the business raked in was significantly higher, giving a P/CF of (62.63 / 5.28) = 11.86, well under the P/E of 17.24. This is a positive sign the company may be undervalued, as Wall Street focuses on P/E to a much larger extent.
5) Price to Free Cash Flow (P/FCF)What does it tell you?
Same as P/CF, except we subtract out cash needed to replace obsolete equipment and ongoing maintenance expenses. This is considered "free cash flow", that the company can use however it sees fit to reward shareholders. Examples of use of this free cash can be share buybacks, dividend payouts, or investment in growth opportunities.How do you calculate it?
Free Cash Flow = Operating Cash Flow - Depreciation
This is a simple generalization - most textbooks will say to use Capital Expenditures instead of Depreciation. But MagicDiligence feels this is the best equation for the majority of stocks, as Capital Expenditures often includes growth based investments such as new stores or plants.
Price to Free Cash Flow = Stock Price / Free Cash Flow per Share (ttm)What's good or bad?
Again, if a company can generate more free cash than it reports in earnings, this is the sign of a very well run business. Companies that generate free cash flow well under earnings generally require a lot of capital investment to sustain the business - an undesirable trait.Simple example
From Johnson and Johnson's 5.28 of cash flow per share, we deduct 0.96 per share of depreciation expense, which is roughly equivalent to maintenance costs. This leaves us with a free cash flow per share of 4.32. Therefore P/FCF is (62.63 / 4.32) = 14.51. This is still well under the P/E of 17.24, a positive sign.
6) EBIT / Enterprise Value (Earnings Yield)What does it tell you?
This is the second "golden statistic" of the Magic Formula. In effect, Earnings Yield is the inverse of P/E, but also subtracts out variables such as tax rate and investment income, while adding in the effects of debt. It tells you the percentage of earnings you are getting for each share of stock.How do you calculate it?
EBIT stands for "earnings before interest and taxes". This is also known as operating earnings (see last week's article for details).
Enterprise value is simply market capitalization plus debt. It represents the price a suitor would have to pay to acquire all of the company.
Earnings yield is simply the quotient of these two statistics:
Earnings Yield = (Operating Earnings / Enterprise Value)What's good or bad?
Joel Greenblatt decided to use this formula because it is a reliable measure of valuation between companies, regardless of industry. Because of this, a true "good" or "bad" value can be obtained. Look for over 9% earnings yield as the sign of a relatively cheap stock.Simple example
Earnings yield is calculated more on an overall basis instead of on per share figures. Johnson and Johnson reported operating earnings of 13.7 billion for 2007. Currently, market cap is 181 billion and debt is 9.5 billion, leading to an enterprise value of 190 billion. Earnings yield is (13.7 / 190) = 0.0721, or 7.21%. This is not bad, but below what is required to make the Magic Formula screen.
Disclosure: Steve owns no stocks referenced here.
Joel Greenblatt and MagicFormulaInvesting.com are not associated in any way with this website. Neither Mr. Greenblatt or MagicFormulaInvesting.com endorse this website's investment opinions, strategy, or products. Investment recommendations on this website are not chosen by Mr. Greenblatt, nor are they based on Mr. Greenblatt's proprietary investment model, and are not chosen by MagicFormulaInvesting.com. Magic Formula® is a registered trademark of MagicFormulaInvesting.com, which has no connection to this website. The information on this website is for informational purposes only and solely represents the views and opinions of the author. No warranty is provided or implied as to the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of this information. This information may not be construed as investment advice of any kind, nor can it be relied upon as the basis for stock trades. The proprietor of this website is not responsible in any way for losses or damages resulting from the use of this information. Alexander Online Properties is not a registered investment advisor. All logos are trademarked properties of their respective companies.
© 2008-2013 Alexander Online Properties.